Our website is set to allow the use of cookies. For more information and to change settings click here. If you are happy with cookies please click "Continue" or simply continue browsing. Continue.

International Family Law

The leading authority on international family law

08 NOV 2012

The criminalisation of consensual sexual relationships between adult siblings Stübing v Germany (App No 43547/08) [2012] ECHR 656)and human rights:

In April 2012, the European Court of Human Rights ruled that Germany had not unjustifiably infringed Patrick Stübing's right under Art 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights. Patrick had been convicted of incest under the German Civil Code and sentenced to prison for having an adult consensual sexual relationship with his sister, Susan Karolewski. The couple had had four children together.

The Court's decision raises two questions. Was the Court adopting a conciliatory approach towards the margin of appreciation enjoyed by Convention States or was it simply abdicating responsibility and avoiding any serious legal analysis of the emotive, social, and ethical issues which surround adult sibling consensual incest?

The decision illustrates the unavoidable tension facing the Court in balancing the rights of a State to self-determination against the human rights of the individual. This is particularly so when there is no consensus amongst States about the complex moral values which underpin an applicant's claim.

The decision has led to a major debate about the basis of the incest taboo for adult siblings and whether there remains any justification for States to use criminal or civil sanctions in an attempt to maintain the taboo.

By Mary Welstead, Fellow at the Child Advocacy Programme, Harvard Law School and Visiting Professor, University of Buckingham

This article appeared appears in the November 2012 issue of International Family Law.

International Family Law Practice, The

International Family Law Practice, The


Provides comprehensive coverage of the international elements of English family law

Available in Lexis®Library
International Family Law Journal

International Family Law Journal

The practice title for family lawyers engaged in/dealing with issues European and worldwide

Available in Lexis®Library