Our website is set to allow the use of cookies. For more information and to change settings click here. If you are happy with cookies please click "Continue" or simply continue browsing. Continue.

Family Law

The leading authority on all aspects of family law

18 JUN 2012

Financial orders after divorce: a category error?

Peter Graham Harris
Oxford Centre for Family Law and Policy, DSPI, University of Oxford

There is a strong case for providing legal certainty in the law governing the civil or criminal liability of individuals by promulgating rules that allow citizens to predict whether they are or would be liable for certain acts. However, the argument for retaining judicial discretion in disposing of cases once liability has been established (whether by way of a criminal sentence, damages or other remedy) is widely accepted as necessary to securing a just outcome in individual cases. However, in the case of financial orders on divorce there appears to be some enthusiasm for eroding judicial discretion and denying parties that element of justice in determining disputes, for example, by introducing formulae or fixed rules of division.  That apparent contradiction may arise from a failure of commentators to recognise that in most disputes about financial resources on divorce, liability (for example parenthood or marital or divorce status) is not in issue. What is in issue is the just disposal of the admitted claim given the individual facts of the case. That 'category error', it is suggested, may explain in part why many commentators argue for diminishing judicial discretion in favour of arbitrary rules in disposing of family cases, while resisting such an approach in other areas of civil as well as criminal law.

To read the rest of this article, see July [2012] Family Law journal.

To log on to Family Law Online or to request a free trial click here

Family Court Practice, The

(Red Book)

The Red Book is the acknowledged authority on practice and procedure

More Info from £498.00
Available in Lexis®Library


Law, Practice and Precedents

This work provides commentary, checklists, procedural guides and precedents on the subject in a...