CARE PROCEEDINGS: Re D (A Child) [2010] EWCA Civ 1000

15 SEP 2010

(Court of Appeal; Mummery, Hughes and Stanley Burnton LJJ; 10 August 2010)

The mother had a learning disability. The children were removed from the parents care because of neglect and care orders were made. The children were eventually returned to the parents and the care orders were discharged on the basis of a report by the social worker that the parents had made real changes. There was a subsequent allegation by a third child that the father had kicked and punched him which led to the removal of all six children for a short period. All but the complainant later returned to the parents but then removed again because of an allegation by a fourth child. A psychological assessment of the parents concluded that the personality of parents, especially the mother, meant they could not parent one or more of the children. The issue for the Family Division judge was whether this evidence should prevail over empirical evidence, which was that the parents were coping sufficiently well. The judge suggested that the psychological evidence was infected with ideological zeal and lacking in objectivity.  The local authority appealed.

The judge must weigh all of the evidence taken together and had been entitled to prefer the empirical evidence that the parents were capable of caring for their children to that of the expert psychologist. The test under s 31(2) Children Act 1989 was an objective one. The use of intemperate language in highly charged care proceedings must be avoided.

__________________________________________________________________

Family Law Reports

Family Law Reports are relied upon by the judiciary, barristers and solicitors and the reports are cited daily in court and in judgments.

They contain verbatim case reports of every important Family Division, Court of Appeal, House of Lords and European courts case, and also includes practice directions, covering the whole range of family law, public and private child law.

Family Law

journal

"the principal (monthly) periodical dealing with contemporary issues" Sir Mark Potter P

More Info from £49.00
Available in Family Law Online
Family Law Online

Family Law Online

Get a FREE trial today! The fastest way to access the latest law reports, case law, commentary,...

Available in Family Law Online