Our website is set to allow the use of cookies. For more information and to change settings click here. If you are happy with cookies please click "Continue" or simply continue browsing. Continue.

Employment Law

Legal guidance - compliance - software

09 OCT 2014

Woodhouse v West North West Homes Leeds Ltd UKEAT/0007/12; [2013] IRLR 773; (2014) EMPLR 040

Edward  Benson


5 June 2013

Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT)

HHJ Hand QC, Mr M Clancy and Mr M Worthington

Dismissals or any other detriment imposed because of the way a person has made complaints of discrimination may not amount to victimization if the way the complaints were made can be genuinely separated from the complaints themselves (Martin v Devonshires Solicitors). But, says the EAT in this case, Martin was an exceptional case where Mr Martin had repeatedly made false allegations of discrimination based on his paranoid delusions about events which had never happened. These wasted management time and were likely to continue to do so.

W made repeated complaints of discrimination. Two of them were partially upheld. He was eventually dismissed. The tribunal rejected W’s complaint of victimization, saying that the facts of this case were on ‘all fours’ with those in Martin.

The EAT disagreed. Although most of his complaints were found to be false, W genuinely believed they had occurred and this was not a case, like Martin, where the complaints were based on paranoid delusions about events which had never happened. Martin, according to the EAT, was exceptional.

Different divisions of the EAT, however, have different views on this. In Panayiotou v Chief Constable of Hampshire, [2014] IRLR 500, the EAT comments there is no need for the circumstances to be ‘exceptional’ to enable disclosures to be distinguished from the manner in which they were made.
Law of Termination of Employment, The

Law of Termination of Employment, The

Authoritative analysis of the rules governing termination of employment provides coverage of the...

Jordan Publishing Employment Law

Jordan Publishing Employment Law

"exceptional value for money in today's challenging legal environment" John Mitton, PG Legal

Available in Lexis®Library