Our website is set to allow the use of cookies. For more information and to change settings click here. If you are happy with cookies please click "Continue" or simply continue browsing. Continue.

Employment Law

Legal guidance - compliance - software

09 OCT 2014

Scottish Prison Service v Laing UKEATS/0060/12; [2013] IRLR 859; (2014) EMPLR 039

Edward  Benson


14 May 2013

Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT)

Lady Stacey, Mr P Hunter and Mr M Sibbald

Treating employees inconsistently by dismissing one but not dismissing another for the same misconduct can make the dismissal unfair unless there are good reasons for distinguishing them. Paul v East Surrey District Health Authority established that the question to be asked is whether the reasons for the differences in treatment were ‘so irrational that no employer could reasonably have accepted them’.

L was one of four prison officers dismissed for their involvement in and/or failure to intervene in an assault on a prisoner. One of the four was reinstated on appeal but the dismissals of the other three, including L, were upheld. L complained to a tribunal this inconsistent treatment made his dismissal unfair. The reasons the appeal board gave for reinstating the other officer were that he had been outside the room in which the assault occurred and may not have seen it; he was working in a location he rarely worked in with staff and prisoners he had never worked with; he knew nothing of their working regime; there had been no handover or orientation to familiarize him with the prison management style of the other three officers.

The EAT held that those were rational and acceptable reasons for distinguishing L from the officer whose appeal was allowed. The appeal board was familiar with the working environment and the prison officers’ code of conduct and was therefore in a good position to judge the relative seriousness of the officer’s failures.
Jordan Publishing Employment Law

Jordan Publishing Employment Law

"exceptional value for money in today's challenging legal environment" John Mitton, PG Legal

Available in Lexis®Library
Social Media in the Workplace

Social Media in the Workplace

A Handbook

This book is intended as a handbook for advisers to employers, providing an overview of the...

Available in Lexis®Library