CJD v Royal Bank of Scotland  CSIH 86; (2014) EMPLR 047
Inner House, Court of Session
Lady Paton, Lord Bracadale and Lord Drummond Young
For a tribunal to conclude that a dismissal for conduct was fair, the employer must establish that the conduct ‘reflected in some way upon the employer-employee relationship’.
D was dismissed for allegedly assaulting his girlfriend in whose flat he was living. The police had charged him with assault. D admitted he had pushed his girlfriend onto a sofa but claimed he did so in self-defence as she was scratching his face. His employer dismissed him even though accepting that he was acting in self-defence.
The Court of Session, upholding the decision of the tribunal, held the dismissal was unfair because the employers had not established a legitimate reason for dismissal. To rely on conduct as a reason, the conduct had to reflect in some way on the employer-employee relationship. Pushing his girlfriend onto a sofa in response to her scratching him could not reflect in any way on the employer-employee relationship.
Jordan Publishing Employment Law Series
Examines how employment documents can be used to help manage home and host country immigration,...